Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.70 - based on 1889 reviews

It was our first experience staying at The Chelsea House even just one day and it wasn’t long enough! How wonderful the staff were and when we entered our room, we were pleasantly surprised. All attention was paid to every detail. So relaxing , just what we needed. I loved the gardens and unique flora and fauna in and around the property. My favorite moment was “floating” in the pool staring up at the most beautiful coconut tree. The staff were extremely polite and willing to attend any of your needs. Breakfast in the garden very memorable. I know we will be back but hopefully for more days. We were so please to be walking distance from the Key West Light House and Ernest Hemingway’s home. Definitely the feel of Key West.

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

5 / 5


We always love getting away to Key West and this is the second time staying at the Chelsea House and as much as we enjoyed it the first time, this time was even better as our room #13 was very comfortable. We walked a lot during our stay but it was nice to come back in the afternoon for a cool swim then off to Duval in the evening.

The staff is always very friendly & helpful.

We will be back!!

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

4 / 5


This charming guest house is situated perfectly for walking to most of the attractions and only one block off of Duval Street means easy access to the hustle-bustle when the mood strikes. With the Lighthouse next door and Hemmigway’s home right across the street, how could we go wrong?

The staff here was very friendly–we felt like we were special guests from the moment we checked in. Ronnie was happy to assist with directions or suggestions and housekeeping was fast, efficient and happily worked around our schedule.

The light breakfast buffet by the pool in the morning was a nice way to ease into the day and a cocktail in the afternoon at the Mojito Bar became a ritual.

Our only bump was the mini-fridge which was somewhat iced over and then decided to thaw itself during the first night, but maintenance was there first thing (as soon as we were ready for them) to come in and replace it with a new unit. Perfecto!

While our dining spanned the gamut from a light lunch at Banana Cafe to a stunning dinner at Latitudes, I think our favorite meal was a traditional breakfast at Amigo’s the day of our departure. The Juevos Rancheros rocked!!

Thank you so much to all the staff at the Lighthouse. We had a marvelous time!

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


This was our second stay at Key Lime Inn this year. We were there in July to celebrate our anniversary. We stayed in one of your cute bungalows and just loved it. This time we brought our visiting friends from TX with us. I specifically wanted to stay at Key Lime again, not only because we had such a great experience last time, but also because I wanted our friends to really experience the charm of Key West, which I feel Key Lime Inn represents beautifully.

I work in a Spa in a luxury hotel in Coral Gables so I  am very conscious of customer service. Your staff is wonderful.  Michelle, at the front desk, was very professional and helpful. Everyone else on site always acknowledged us with a smile and joyful greeting.

The breakfast is simple but filling. The Pool is great for a cool down after a day in the sun and the parking is an absolute blessing. The rooms are clean, cool and beautifully decorated.

Since we live so close, we will probably visit Key West several times a year and we will definitely be staying at Key Lime every time.

Thank you again for making our time in Key West an absolute delight!!

desiree mcfarlin

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


My husband and I booked a 4-day stay a beautiful resort in Ducks Key Cove to celebrate our 32nd Wedding Anniversary. We arrived on a Sunday and everything was beautiful, however we awoke on Monday morning to jack hammering and extremely noisy construction work. There was nowhere on the resort to escape the noise and absolutely ruined any chances of my husband and I enjoying a quiet get-away anniversary trip.

We quickly checked out and headed to Key West with no reservations in hand.  We’ve never been to the Keys so wasn’t sure where to stay.  We looked at a couple of reviews online and found positive comments about Key Lime Inn.  We made our reservation 15 minutes before we arrived. We explained our situation to the Front Desk clerk (Danielle?) and she quickly upgraded our room to a King size suite with a private porch and mini fridge at no extra charge.  Awesome!  The room was a great size and super clean.  We’ve already recommended another couple to Key Lime Inn who plan to visit the Keys soon.  Thanks for saving our Anniversary trip!

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


My wife and I would like to thank the staff at the Cypress House for such a wonderful experience. We booked for the weekend for our wedding anniversary. When we arrived, the staff member who checked us in was courteous, friendly and welcoming. She told us about the property, gave us a tour and even walked us to our room. She explained all the details we needed to know thoroughly.

The room was very nice, comfortable and spacious. We felt right at home. My wife and I loved the fact that we were a block from all the action on Duval. It was easy for us to go out and return to our room when we liked.

The breakfast provided by Cypress House was delicious and fresh. It was a great way to start the day.

Thank you Cypress House for helping make our stay an amazing experience and left us with wonderful memories of our anniversary weekend in Key West. The next time we are in Key West, we would happily stay there again.

All the best,

Jose M.

 

 

 

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


We recently stayed at the Key Lime Inn and really enjoyed ourselves.  I only have a couple of suggestions: 1)  We stayed in Room 33, one of the rooms near the pool.  The lights outside of these rooms are quite bright.  It would be nice to be able to either turn off the outside light late at night, or have a black-out shade to pull down to block some of the light.  2)  A pencil and pad of paper in each room would have been useful.  All the staff I dealt with were polite, helpful, and accommodating.

Thank you!  We plan to come and stay again.

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


I can’t recommend the Cypress House enough! After a delayed flight, I arrived in Key West after the front desk closed.  Not to worry — I was quickly referred to the night manager, who met me at Cypress House within 5 minutes of my arrival.  I was then escorted to my room, which was absolutely lovely.  The bedroom was actually quite large, and the bathroom was beautifully updated.  Everything was spotless, and the bed was really comfortable.  I did the official check-in the next day, and the gentleman who checked us in was incredibly helpful — he recommended a couple of beaches, grocery stores, and the best brunch spot on the island!  He even let us borrow a few towels from the hotel to take to the beach with us.  Not only is the staff super nice and accommodating, but the location of Cypress House itself is unbeatable — it’s a stone’s throw from Duval Street and The Porch, which was my favorite bar.  I will definitely stay at Cypress House during my next stay in Key West!

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


We loved everything about our 4 days at Albury Court.  It was ideally located near the harbor and close enough to walk to the attractions we wanted to see. The room was beautifully furnished, the colors were relaxing and it was spotlessly clean. The staff was very helpful, friendly, always smiling and had a good knowledge of the area. The front desk staff got us bikes that we loved riding around town, really made us feel like we were locals.

Continental breakfast was served by the pool at the back of the hotel and the choices were excellent, we really like the local baked goods. Overall, we had a wonderful time in Key West and Albury Court was a big part of it. Thank you and we’ll be back again!

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


We had an absolute perfect stay at the Lighthouse Court Hotel in Key West.

The property is very clean and nice, it is quiet and good to relax. The staff is very friendly. We will definitely come back.

By: on October 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5