Guest Testimonials | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.
Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.69 - based on 813 reviews

This hotel was really perfect for our stay. We stayed for just a weekend, 2 nights and 3 days. Upon arrival, the front desk greeted me by first name, having prior knowledge to guests checking in that day. I had read reviews of the hotel prior, saying rooms were too small and not comfortable-so I was a little worried. But, luckily those reviews were very wrong! We loved our room, we thought it had the perfect amount of charm and style. It was very up to date, perfect amount of space for just the two of us. Everything about our stay was wonderful, and the front desk was very informative whenever we had questions. I would absolutely stay here again! It’s within walking distance of Duval Street which was perfect for us as well! I was definitely more than satisfied staying here.

By: on March 10, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


My name is Pam Hummel, and my daughter and I recently stayed at
Lighthouse Court Hotel on a trip to Key West.

I am writing to let you how much we enjoyed our stay at your hotel. The
staff we dealt with were absolutely wonderful! Jeremiah and Denice are
both assets to have as your front desk receptionists. They were very
helpful in every aspect: accommodating us for an additional night,
keeping our bags while rooms were being changed, giving restaurant
recommendations, setting us up with a rental car, offering suggestions
on events and activities and helping to check us in with our airline.
They made us feel like our enjoyment was just as important to them as it
was to us. As I stated previously, they were wonderful!

On a separate note, I thought I would give you some feedback on our room
situations. We were in two different rooms during our stay. The first,
H3, the room and private bathroom were clean and comfortable. The only
thing I think is worth mentioning, is the carpet. Although it appeared
clean, to the bare foot, it felt like wax, making me think it might not
be as clean as originally thought.

The second room, J1, was a pleasant change. I think the wood flooring
works much better in a place where sand and dirt are just a “given”. The
overall room was clean and comfortable. There are only a few “cosmetic”
things I think are worth mentioning. Because this room is designed for
more occupants, I think having a second mirror would be beneficial.
Currently, the only mirror available is located in the bathroom which
makes it difficult to “get ready” when the bathroom is in use by others.
The shower curtain needs to be slightly longer. The shower water sprays
water out onto the bathroom floor. And last, but not least, a full size
ironing board (in both rooms) would be nice. The small ones are just so
hard to work with.

I hope you do not get offended by my “observations/recommendations”, but
believe me, these few little things were of no real concern to our
enjoyment. I really enjoyed staying with you, and plan to do so again in
the future. I just thought some comments would be helpful to your
continued success.

Thank you, again, for such a great experience! I hope to see you again
soon.

Sincerely,

Pamela Hummel

By: on March 8, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


The staff was delightful and very helpful.  Room was clean, but a bit small. Good location, easy walk to the ferry and to Duval street activities.

By: on March 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

4 / 5


Every staff member we encounter were both courteous and friendly.  Anytime we needed assistance for any reason, the person present at the front desk was willing to provide our necessities.  Our room exceeded our expectations.  We were a little leary since it was our first time in Key West.  We were also extremely please that our room were kept up everyday although we had late starts.  I thought that there was a specific time line to housekeeping but was pleasantly surprise each day with the cleanliness of our room upon arrival to a long day.  A Far as checking-in and checking-out, this process was effortless.  I would definitely recommend the Albury Court Hotel.  The only complaint would be that our trip was too short.  Our entire experience was extraordinary, far exceeded our expectations.  Everyone we encountered was extremely friendly.  My wife and I are having withdrawals to say the least.  Thank you for making our experience memorable.

By: on March 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


We arrived for our first stay in Key West for 2 nights. Location was excellent. Close and within walking distance of all attractions yet far enough off the beaten path. Our rooms were like cute, pine lined bungalows . Very quaint. Clean facilities with excellent housekeeping and front desk staff. Adequate pool with cozy seating area. Very nice continental breakfast. Front desk kindly held our bags after checkout til departure. Enjoyed our stay here immensely and would definitely stay here again. Thank you Albury staff!

By: on March 6, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


We really enjoyed our stay at the Key Lime Inn from reception to departure.  Neat bungalow layout was very functional, private and quiet.  The Inn had good off-street parking and was convenient to Duval, so we walked to all the sights and restaurants.  Loved the Seven Fish restaurant!  Will definitely stay at the Key Lime Inn and strongly recommend to others.

By: on March 5, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


A very nice stay this past week.  I’ve been down about 6 times and stayed a variety of places, this was near the top.  Roomy clean and quiet room – the unexpected upgrade was a very nice touch!  Room staff was good and efficient.  two comments:  1. the pool area – you have limited space which probably makes this impossible put it sure would be nice to be able to lounge right at the pool.  I think it would encourage folks to hang out more.  The liming hour should really be longer than an hour – each evening we went we saw wasted food get scooped up right at the stroke of the liming ending and worst yet, guest showing up late or running to get a refill as it was swiped away.  What harm would it do when folks are paying top dollar for your inn to leave things out a bit longer or until the food/drinks are gone???

By: on March 5, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House

4 / 5


This was my second spring vacation in the keys and my second visit to the Lighthouse Court Hotel. The location is the perfect distance from the beach, duval street and many other attractions such as The Southernmost Point and the infamous Ernest Hemingway House. Lighthouse provided ear plugs and one of the best continental breakfasts ever. The room was also flawless. Very spacious, well decorated and comfortable. I would definitely stay here again!!

By: on March 5, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We recently visited Key West to celebrate our sons 21st birthday! What better place to enjoy turning 21 than Key West! On our trip we were lucky enough to stay at the Merlin Guesthouse! I must say what an amazing place to stay! The staff was very friendly and helpful. We stayed in the one bedroom cottage 18 and my dad stayed in a queen room 11! Our room was very clean and inviting! It had a pullout queen couch so cottage fit 4 of us perfect! My dads queen room was also perfect! The Merlin Guesthouse is located just far enough off the “main drag” that it is very quiet! We got a great nights sleep both nights we were there! Our rooms had everything we needed so we never had to request anything from housekeeping. The check in and check out process smooth! We  would defiantly stay here again And I will recommend the Merlin Guesthouse to any and all my friends traveling to Key West!! Thank you for helping make our sons 21st birthday one he will never forget! We all can’t wait to come visit again!

By: on March 4, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

5 / 5


We just stayed 3 nights at Cypress House.  Although we have traveled several times to Key West, this was our first stay at Cypress House and it was by far our best experience.  Every member of the staff was extremely helpful and very professional.  We loved the king suite with the porch.  We will definitely be back.

By: on March 4, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House

5 / 5