Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.74 - based on 5193 reviews

Our stay at Lighthouse Court was perfect, from my first phone call to the end of stay check out. When I called for information, Jennifer  listened to our plan of what we wanted to do in Key West, and suggested the Lighthouse Court because of location, and let us know we would not need to rent a car. She was most helpful. I called again later after we made our airline reservations to ask about late arrival and was again given helpful information, and phone numbers to call in case our flights were late.

Our flight from DFW was very late leaving so we missed our connection to Key West. We could not get another flight until after noon the next day and had to spend a stressful night in Miami without our luggage. We were so disappointed to miss the first night and half day of our short vacation, but were so happy when we got a new reservation notice from Lighthouse Court showing that the charge for the missed night had been removed before we even arrived.  Thank you!! Not all hotels or resorts would do that. During our entire stay everyone was so friendly, helpful and professional. The room and grounds were spotless and lovely. My friend and I both commented several times about how wonderful the staff was the whole time. I wish we had gotten names, but I would need to list everyone. Thank you all.

The location was also perfect for walking to everything we wanted to see. Two of our favorite places, The Hemingway House, and the Six Toed Cat Restaurant were right across the street. Check in was easy, and the staff  printed our boarding passes for us before we left, and even stored our luggage after check out until time for our flight.

We would definitely recommend this hotel to friends visiting Key West, and hope to return again.

By: on October 30, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We absolutely loved our stay.  The room was adorable and comfortable.  A bit loud on Eaton street, but that has nothing to do with hotel.  Fantastic location otherwise- easy to walk to everything.  Loved the breakfast by the pool and taking coffee back to my room to enjoy on the porch.  Will definitely be back!!!

By: on October 29, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


I booked 3 rooms for 3 couples for a 2 night stay.  The entire staff was very courteous and helpful.  We were given 3 upstairs rooms across the street.  Ayanna made suggestions for sites and meals and offered coupons for both.  The rooms are small but comfortable, well appointed and clean. It was nice having a coffee maker and fridge.  We gathered on the balcony outside our rooms for a glass of wine and key lime pie one evening. It was very pleasant.  We also spent an evening at the pool and were the only guests using it at the time.  The breakfast had variety and tasty options. The coffee was great.  The property is several blocks from Duval but it is walkable. The best part of our stay was the attentive and helpful staff.  Thank you.

By: on October 29, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


Excellent for our stay in Key West. Clean, great amenities, unique rooms, great breakfast and pool area, quiet location.

By: on October 29, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


The room was clean and private. The pool area was perfect and private, with a wonderful continental breakfast. We were originally concerned with the distance to the center of town; we didn’t have a car, and really wanted to walk everywhere. This is possible from this location, as long as you have your walking shoes on. It was actually a great way to work off a day of food and drink consumption! The staff was friendly and accommodating. I would recommend the Albury Court in Key West!

By: on October 29, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

4 / 5


We couldn’t have imagined a better place to spend a few days of our honeymoon!  Thank you for an enjoyable time.

By: on October 28, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


I booked Albury Court online for 3 couples for a 2 night stay in Key West.  All the rooms were clean and comfortable with all the necessary amenities.  The breakfast buffet included several choices each morning.  We used the pool one evening and were the only ones in it.  We took advantage of the well furnished balcony outside of our rooms to enjoy a glass of wine and Key lime pie one evening.  The hotel is a several block walk from Duval St. but it is manageable. The hotel staff was exceptional.  Everyone was courteous and friendly.  Ayanna was especially helpful.  She offered suggestions on things to do, how to get around, and lots of coupons for attractions and food.  Thank you to the entire staff of the Albury Court for a very pleasant experience.

By: on October 28, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


When we arrived in old town Key West, we we’re a little overwhelmed by the traffic on the way in. The week-end was approaching and so were the crowds. A big part of the reason we chose Chelsea House was for its near proximity to all the action yet not so close that we listened to it all night. We wanted to park our car and venture out on foot or bicycles. For this reason alone we agree that we would be very comfortable recommending it to friends. Beyond that, we also enjoy the old town architecture and feel, the Chelsea House filled the bill here on both accounts. Our room was cozy and clean and we appreciated the way they managed to re-configure this old home to serve their purpose without taking away its style and charm. We took advantage of the complimentary breakfast while enjoying the grounds on beautiful Key West mornings. We walked to all of the venues that we had intended on seeing during our stay so when we checked out, we were completely satisfied with our choice to book there. When you are at the mercy of pictures from the internet while choosing a place to stay, it’s nice when people still abide by truth in advertising.

By: on October 28, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

4 / 5


This place is amazing.  The rooms are awesome and extremely clean.  The hotel is a few blocks away from Duval Street but a great walk to get there.  Not only would I recommend Albury Court but I will be staying here again.  The front desk staff is top notch and helped me out with information about an event on a neighboring island.  The breakfast they offer around the pool is so inviting and  just the right amount of food to hold you over to eat at the amazing restaurants around town.  Some of our favorite places to eat.

Hog Fish Bar & Grill (Stock Island)

No Name Pub (Big Pine Key)

B O Fish house (Key West)

 

By: on October 27, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


Maria was very helpful throughout our stay.  Everyone was professional and courteous and knowledgeable about both the hotel and the area and make suggestions on good restaurants to try.  The room was clean and comfortable.  The check-in process was a little frustrating but the individual was new.  I would recommend your hotel to friends and in fact have already done that.  The pricing for overnight stays in Key West are becoming so high that I think the normal income traveler will not pick it as a destination soon due to the cost of hotel rooms.  If they continue to rise, we will not likely pick Key West are our vacation destination.  This has nothing directly to do with our hotel stay.  It is merely an observation of the rise of cost.

Thanks.

By: on October 27, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5