Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.75 - based on 5747 reviews

We recently stayed at the Merlin Guest House, our second stay with the Historic Key West Inns hotels this year. The first trip was to their Chelsea House Hotel. Both stays were amazing but we preferred the location of Merlin Guest House. Linda was on site when we checked in and departed and she runs a tight ship. Towels were always at the pool, ice replenished by the tea and the pool was a perfect temp. We have already booked our next stay in December! We have been to Key West several times over the last few years and we will never stay anywhere BUT in a Historic Key West Inns property!

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

5 / 5


My friend and I went to Key West for a girls weekend. We enjoyed the hotel-it was very clean. Everyone in the reviews speak about a big white cat, but he was barely around-no issue at all. We were close to everything and were able to get home safely.  Being one block off duval makes it a great spot.  Good morning breakfast. All in all, I’d go back.

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

5 / 5


Very professional staff. Lynne at the front desk was very helpful making sure we knew of the best places to go for meals and to have the best stay. Would highly recommend this place to friends. The outside breakfast every morning was fantastic. All staff were very friend and helpful. Can’t wait to come back.

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


My husband and I stayed at the Chelsea House on 8-21-16. I am so glad we stayed here. The room was very clean and beautiful along with the property. The staff was wonderful! They made sure they answered all our questions and pointed out all the points of interest. They also told us about the history of the Chelsea House.

This trip was my first time in Key West and I can say for certain that I will stay at the Chelsea House Hotel again! We will definitely recommend the Chelsea House to all our family and friends!

Thank you for your hospitality! See you again soon!

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


Let me start off saying that Lighthouse Court Hotel, not to mention Key West, is our all time favorite place. This is our 3rd time in key west and I have chosen Lighthouse Court every time. Everyone was so nice when we checked in and the staff was so friendly. We love your location, it’s quiet and yet so close to everything key west has to offer. My husband and I had the best time on our recent trip (and all our trips there.) We love coming for the lobster festival. Our room was so very nice and we had such a great location. It’s also great that there is a continental breakfast in the morning if you didn’t want to go out to eat and having the mojito bar there is also Fun. We didn’t have to wait for our rooms everything was ready.  We checked in and unpacked and went for cocktails which were so good. Great selection of beer and drinks.

The only thing I have to say is that it ended too soon and then it was back to reality. The Historic Key West Inns hotels are the nicest places. I have a sister that stayed at their Key Lime Inn and she loved it and my daughter and her husband stayed at their Merlin Guest House and they loved it. They are quaint and beautiful and that’s what we love and if that’s what your looking for then the Historic Key West Inns hotels are for you. Every time we come back we will choose Lighthouse Court.  I definetly recommend Blue Heaven for breakfast and the six toe cat as well. We ate at so many places we never had a bad meal. We also highly recommend the Roof Top Cafe and the Cuban restaurant and of course sunset at Mallory square. We discovered the waterfront brewery who had awesome beers and even better appetizers.  The lobster fest was awesome. Lobster all day, how can you beat that!!

I could go on forever but overall it was a wonderful and much needed vacation. Thank you so much!!!

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We would just like to say how wonderful your hotel is. First and foremost, when we arrived we were very stressed because our luggage was lost. We encountered Melissa who was extremely nice and ensured us that when our luggage arrived she would notify us immediately. Once our luggage arrived and we were able to relax, we had an awesome stay.

Our room was so quaint, and felt like we had our own private cottage, not like the big hotels where you can hear your neighbors. We were on our honeymoon and it was so romantic of a hotel. The location was also excellent. We would totally recommend your hotel to anyone visiting the Keys, and have already decided that our next time visiting that the Lighthouse Court would be our hotel of choice. Thank you very much to the staff for all the great service they provided.

 

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


After staying in two four star hotel properties making our way down to Key West, my husband and I wanted an equal Key West style property for our one night here. We chose the Key Lime Inn property for it’s charm and location. We were not disappointed!

The hotel was updated and clean and there was a lovely continental breakfast in the courtyard. Our only small complaint was the A/C in the room kicked on and off during the night and woke us up frequently. Not sure that anything can be done about this since it is a standalone unit, but thought it was worth mentioning. Thank you again. We will be back!

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

4 / 5


I always try to book local authentic hotels on my trips either within the US or abroad, I just don’t like the chain hotel feel while I’m vacationing, perfectly fine for business but not for pleasure! Sometimes they can be hit and miss but the staff and the facility at the Cypress House Hotel were right on target for a great local feel experience.

The rooms themselves were clean, tidy and everything we needed. Sure the bathroom was a little small, but that didn’t bother us. We spent very little time in there and little time in our room anyway! The staff were great, shout outs to Dennis and Scott for being such great hosts. These guys were courteous and very pleasant all through our trip. They went out of their way effortlessly to make sure you were taken care of. 5 star service from these guys that’s for sure. This was my first time in Key West and when I come back I know where I’ll be staying.

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


We stayed Only 1 night but we left Our heart there because this place was absolutely amazing! We received a free upgrade to a beautiful king room with a special view of the Hemingway house across the street, really awesome! The hotel is really close to all main tourist attractions of the island and to the commercial Duval street.

The breakfast served next to the pool was very good as well! I will advise it for all the people, families, couples. A special thanks to Laura for her kindness and her precious advice on what to do on the island and restaurants too! We look forward to come back to this paradise again very soon.

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


Our stay was delightful. Nice swimming pool, close to shops/dining/rental golf carts. Breakfast was very good. The rooms were beautiful, and the bathrooms spotless.

By: on August 23, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5