Guest Testimonials | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.
Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.68 - based on 1360 reviews

 

Very comfortable facility with all the needs and wants for an amazing vacation. We took our children this year and they enjoyed the pool time. The room was very roomy! It contained a room with 2 queens, living room, kitchen and bathroom. It was perfect. Thank you for a incredible stay!

 

 

By: on September 23, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


 

The proximity to the Hemingway House, Duval Street, and other attractions was fantastic. The office staff was wonderful–especially Jeremiah. We really enjoyed everything.

 

Restaurant Review: 5 Pineapples

915 had exceptional service and food. We went twice. We also loved the key lime pie at the Key Lime Pie Factory, but their homemade key lime ice cream was really outstanding.

Attraction Review: 4 Pineapples

Sebego Catamaran sunset cruise was spectacular, even though it rained

 

 

By: on September 23, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

This was my second stay at the Lighthouse Court and it was just as pleasant as the first. What’s not to like? The staff is extremely courteous and helpful, and everything about the entire hotel is great.

 

Restaurant Review: 4 Pineapples

Being a sports “nut” I always enjoy Jack Flats. They have good food, good service and plenty of big TVs to watch sports any time of year.

Attraction Review: 4 Pineapples

One of the main reasons for going to Key West is to get away from it all and hear some good live music. This trip was no different. You can always find someplace that will have music to your taste no matter what it is and they are all within walking distance.

 

 

By: on September 23, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


 

What a great place to stay in Old Key West. Close to everything with a feel of history.
Not a cookie-cutter hotel.  Thank you.

 

Restaurant Review: 5 Pineapples

Alonzo’s on Front Street

Attraction Review: 5 Pineapples

Hemingway Museum & House

 

 

By: on September 23, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


 

We were unexpectedly upgraded into one of the suites poolside. It added to the ambiance of our anniversary. Your entire staff are the most friendly staff we have ever encountered. We will definitely be back again…

 

Restaurant Review: 5 Pineapples

We ate at a variety of seafood restaurants. It’s hard to select just one favorite

Attraction Review: 5 Pineapples

Definitely recommend the jet ski tour around the island

 

 

By: on September 23, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


 

I have stayed at the Key Lime Inn before and now at the Lighthouse Court. I feel at the Court is like being a guest at a friends house. You feel relaxed and welcomed. Met several very nice people and made new friends.

 

 

By: on September 23, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


 

Key West is a destination to me and any accommodation satisfies me. Yet, my family had a great experience at the Hotel. The staff are very professional, parking availability made it easier to commute, the swimming pool is clean and so convenient for a morning splash for the kids, and above all, a delicious complementary breakfast provided freshly every morning. The hotel’s closeness to the heart of Key West and Duval st. is a main objective, yet your hospitality made it a pleasant vacation.

 

Restaurant Review: 5 Pineapples

We enjoyed the Sunset restaurant the best. It is a unique Key West destination. We were surprised by a street shack “Konch…” that sells authentic Key West food. On our way back from snorkeling the kids insisted on stopping by and satisfying their hungry stomachs by its menu. Konch is a great delicacy and the kids loved their service and their sense of hospitality. They even let them blow the Konch’s horn.

Attraction Review: 5 Pineapples

This time we enjoyed snorkeling. Sunset cruises are great and a lovely dedicated staff made us enjoy the trip

 

 

By: on September 22, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

2nd stay within 3 years. Great staff; easy check-in. Hard to park. Room was satisfactory but prefer the hardwood floors in our former room, although I understand why the carpet is there. Room was directly off the pool. Arrived and room was fresh and ready. Great breakfast out by the pool. Very convenient to Duval and quiet. Will stay at least in another Historic Key West Inn.

 

Restaurant Review: 3 Pineapples

“915 Restaurant on Duval.” Had two levels with two different menus. Very confusing. We wanted the upstairs and got seated at the more expensive and different menu downstairs. Our server said that “it happens frequently”. Offered to move us upstairs with a wait. Decides as others probably do, to stay put. Almost feel it was a bait and switch by the host. Food was just ok for me and better for my wife.

Attraction Review: 5 Pineapples

Can’t remember the company, but was on the far end of the docks near the Marriott. Took the early wave runner tour around Key West. My wife rode for free. Our guide was personable and knowledgeable. Only 3 wave runners and one leader. Had a lot of fun and definitely worth it.

 

 

By: on September 22, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

While we only had one night (and a few hours of the night) at the Lighthouse Court, we loved the room and the location. We were close enough to all the “must see/must do” attractions, yet not so close that we were overwhelmed by the noise or traffic. A few more tables around the pool for breakfast would have helped some seating issues, but nothing that would detract from staying here should the opportunity arise.

 

 

By: on September 22, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

We loved it at Lighthouse Court. The courtyard by the pool is so relaxing, and we enjoyed our self-serve breakfasts there. The location suited us perfectly and Scott at the Cafe/Bar treated us really well. He makes a great sandwich and fantastic cocktails! Thanks, Scott.

 

Restaurant Review: 5 Pineapples

Red Fish Blue Fish does fantastic meals, has a nice vibe, and the service is very good, without feeling intrusive or rushed

Attraction Reviews: 5 Pineapples

Truman’s Little White House was really interesting – we had an excellent guide, who “sold” Truman a newspaper during one of his visits to Key West

 

 

By: on September 22, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5