Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.70 - based on 1889 reviews

We love Key Lime Inn..the king room was big and comfortable, we could not have had a better time. Pool was wonderful and everyone was friendly.

By: on September 15, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


From the moment we booked to the moment we checked out everyone here was amazing! Anything we needed was taken care of immediately! Our room was beautiful and the happy hour everyday at 4:30 wasn’t bad either! Great location in walking distance to everything you could want to see/do in the old town area. Hope to be back soon!

By: on September 15, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


Walking in the front door you felt you were home. Greeted like family, so warm and welcoming. Kelly, Scott and Dennis were GREAT. HOUSEKEEPING,very nice, young lady attending breakfast area very sweet. BIG SMILES ALWAYS. Breakfast selection very nice, afternoon treats were a very nice addition. Made numerous calls to friends in Miami to share Our GEM with them, making sure they enjoyed when they come to KEYS. ENJOYED sitting on patio, relaxing while I wrote my review for TRIPADVISOR. Spoke to other guests, a couple from FRANCE dearly loved CYPRESS HOUSE. Another couple from England/Boston expressed the same review. Interior room decor very nice, patio area very Florida KEY WEST, very well done. Added addition other locations don’t offer in house ALARM CLOCK….ROOSTER CROWING AT 5:30AM…LOVED IT! Planning SPRING TRIP!!!!  Please don’t change anything…you have a WONDERFUL recipe for continued SUCCESS….PEOPLE, Product, Price and LOCATION WE APPRECIATED more than some, having Key West roots. My wife’s mother born in KEY WEST, Grandfather was turtle inspector, cousin was a fisherman, known as POPEYES, did a nail trick at bars to get his drinks….never did tell anyone how he did it. My wife is a Key West CONCH and Florida Pioneer.THANKS AGAIN FOR ALL THE MEMORIES THANKS TO ALL THE STAFF FOR MAKING OUR STAY AN AT HOME FEELING.

By: on September 15, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


We stayed two nights (Sept 10 and 11) and found the hotel conveniently located to Duval Street and the Old Town.  The room was clean, cool and quiet.  Great having off-street parking and breakfast included with the rate.  Staff were extremely helpful and personable.  I’d recommend this small hotel (two  buildings) to friends.  Enjoy your stay!

By: on September 15, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

5 / 5


Our stay at the Albury Court was most pleasant. Everyone was very friendly and for awhile felt like a true Key West local. Location, quality of room, breakfast , treatment all excellent. Would definitely stay there again and highly recommend it to anyone visiting Key West.

By: on September 15, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


We chose the Lighthouse Court Hotel for its price and location. The Inn was just as it was advertised. The rooms were clean and fresh. The pool and surrounding area was just right. The staff was not only friendly, but they were very personable and made you feel like a friend. Robby was especially nice and hooked us up with several BOGO drink coupons. Thanks again for that. The breakfast was typical continental style. I would have liked to see more fresh fruit, but it was still good. Overall the time we spent there was very nice. I would recommend this inn to anyone that is traveling to Key West.

By: on September 13, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


The Merlin is always our first choice of places to stay-the staff is always the friendliest and most welcoming. The rooms are great, housekeeping staff sweet and attentive and Jordan is always up for a brief scratch behind the ears!

By: on September 13, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

5 / 5


I’ve been staying at the Key Lime Inn for the past 12 years. Beautiful property. Excellent service. Ray in reservations is always the best and Michelle at the desk is happy to accommodate anything you might need.  Rooms are always super clean and fresh.  I think I’ve stayed in almost all of them.  Love to rent scooters from Andy’s and ride them right up to my Key Lime Door.  The pool at Key Lime is always super clean.  The location is perfect to walk to Duval and there is a CVS to stop for snacks etc.  The housekeeping staff is really sweet & always smiling.  We love to walk down to Boars Breath for the peel and eat shrimp and listen to Jenn Music.  Really enjoyed Barefoot Billy’s 2 hour jet ski tour around the island  If you are looking for a great meal go see Chantelle at La Tratoria Oceanside, tell her Michelle sent you and make sure you say hi to her mom (She is the hostess). I love to come to Key West at least once a year ,sometimes 3 times if I’m lucky.  I don’t shop hotels,  I just call Ray at Key Lime Inn.  I have the number in my phone and gave it to Giles and Melanie Heuer a couple years ago, and this year to my friend Cheryl Lightfoot when she was headed down to Key West.  So far as I’m concerned Key Lime Inn is the best place to stay in Key West.  Great Beautiful Property, Great Pricing. Most Pleasurable experience.

By: on September 12, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


Our stay at Albury Court was a wonderful experience in Key West. Albury Court is located conveniently to the ferry, boats, restaurants and Duval Street. The room was small but perfect for 2 people. Staff was always available when needed and the room was clean and remodeled recently. I have already referred Albury to a co-worker who is planning a trip to Key West.

By: on September 11, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


To the owner and staff of the Chelsea House Pool & Gardens, This was my first visit to Florida and I must admit that you’ve made it memorable to say the least.  From the moment we (my brother and his wife had also reserved a room) walked in, we immediately felt welcomed. All aspects of our reservations were thoroughly explained to us and to our delight, our rooms had been upgraded also. While exploring around, we discovered better and better angles on which to view the grounds including the pool and gardens. As for our rooms, they were made even more welcoming with the the A/C already cooling the air and the side lamps already turned on with that pleasant glow.We checked in on Thursday Sept. 4th and checked out on Friday the 5th. I regret to say that I didn’t take note of the helpful employees we were lucky enough to be served by on those dates but by reading this review, I’m sure you will know who they are.While in Key West, we of course walked around to visit sites such as the Ernest Hemingway House which has extremely knowledgeable guides to walk us through the house and grounds. Our guide’s name was Chris. We also ate at places like The Burning Tuna with wonderful live entertainment and Jimmy Buffett’s Margaritaville restaurant.All in all, needless to say, my first visit to Key West won’t be my last and neither will my stay at the Chelsea House Pool & Gardens. I’ve already started to rant and rave of both places to friends and family here in eastern Canada.

Until we meet again, Chelsea House Pool & Gardens,

J.Page

By: on September 11, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

5 / 5