Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.70 - based on 2086 reviews

We just got back from a wonderful weekend in Key West.  I took a chance and booked a room at the Key Lime Inn and I was extremely impressed.  This is a first class place to stay.  The room was extremely clean, and very nicely decorated. So much nicer than a commercial hotel room. We had a wonderful experience there, the staff was very helpful and polite.  We are already making plans to a return trip in the Spring.

If you get a chance book your stay here, you will not be let down.  And make sure to get reservations for Better than Sex, a block away..  WOW!!

Todd & Sheri

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


During our 4 nights at the Key Lime Inn in Nov, 2014, we were very impressed with the friendly, professional staff and clean, stylish, comfortable rooms.  The staff was warm, knowledgeable and charming.  Our room was lovely, with welcome extras such as a Keurig coffeemaker, huge flat-screen TV with dozens of channels, real wine glasses and a ceiling fan.  Housekeeping and breakfast attendants were very helpful and thorough.   Our only tiny issue is why we received only 1 bar of soap for two of us, and never another one in 4 days; we managed, moving it from sink to shower, but it seemed a silly oversight with all the extras in the room.  I am sure would have received more had we asked.  And regarding the sights, etc., we did not realize that the hour BEFORE sunset was when visitors should be at Mallory Square or on the coast; we arrived as the sky went dark, exactly on time.  Perhaps the desk could mention it to new visitors.

Thank you for a very nice vacation in a lovely place.

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


My husband and I came to stay at your hotel for two nights this past week. We stumbled across your hotel on an internet search and we booked it based on its overall look and the closeness to Duval Street. We were so happy we chose your hotel!

We were able to park our car and not get back in it until we unfortunately had to go back home. We were greeted by a wonderful woman at the front desk, Robbi. She was extremely nice and very helpful. She even gave us an upgrade to our room. Our suite was so charming! Adorable two room suite with a modern kitchenette, an updated bathroom with a huge shower, our own private porch, and one of the most comfortable beds I have slept in at a hotel. Unfortunately the weather wasn’t the best it could have been so we were able to really enjoy some of the other features the hotel offered but we were able to walk every where from it. The included breakfast wasn’t anything special, local baked goods, some yogurt, coffee and juice. Our stay was so great. We have decided that every time from now on when we go to Key West we only want to stay at the Lighthouse Court Hotel and we will recommend this place to everyone we know.

 

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We had a very nice stay at The Albury Court.  Everything was very much in order, and the room, as well as the staff were great.  The only thing I would change is the type of refrigerator in the room.  It did not seem to have much room in it at all, and we had to throw some food out due to this.  Parking was somewhat of a problem.  One had to catch what one could on the street, or pay for public parking (which is not cheap) down the street.  All in all, it was a very nice stay.

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

4 / 5


My husband & I had the best stay ever!!!! staff was so accommodating!!! breakfast was to die for, is oh so much more than you usually get for continental breakfast. I would definitely shout out for the Key Lime Inn!!

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


Key West for our anniversary was fabulous. We had an amazing time. Our room at the Key Lime Inn was great. It was decorated beautifully in tropical colors. The Tempra pedic mattress made us feel more at home. The staff were very friendly and knew the area well. They had some great recommendations on what to do while we were there. The Key Lime Inn was centrally located in walking distance to everything restaurants, attractions (Hemingway house, light house, butterfly exhibit and lots more). We will definitely be back and stay at Key Lime Inn.

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


Wonderful hotel, with great location.  All staff were extremely friendly and welcoming.  We will definitely be back. Thank you.

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


My trip to Florida began with a flight into Fort Lauderdale to visit my girlfriend who recently relocated there.  After spending a couple days at her place we had a planned visit to Key West. That visit to Key West this past week was both our first, and I hope, will not be the last.

As I’m sure you know, parking isn’t exactly the easiest thing to accommodate with such small streets. However, Kenneth, just so happened to be standing on the sidewalk and asked if we needed help. We did, so he gave us quick and simple “right around the block” directions to park on the one way street located behind the Merlin house… Awesome! Kenneth also happened to be the one to check us into our room. Gave us a quick, but informative, tour of the location as well as some maps for local beaches and tourist hot spots.  I feel ashamed that I could not remember anyone else’s name but I did get the chance to sit and talk briefly with the woman who checked us out. She had moved from Chicago to escape the cold, and although it was a chilly 68 and cloudy the last two days I was there, she assured me that that circumstance rarely happens. I had mentioned how nice it was to be staying so close to everything and she was kind enough to give me a little history of the whole island (I’m a sucker for history, so I loved that). Side note, the breakfast was perfect. Neither my girlfriend or I are big breakfast eaters but the luxury of sitting out by the pool in a pair of shorts enjoying a cup of coffee is such a relaxing delicacy in the month of November for someone from Ohio.  Anyways, aside from Kenneth, every employee couldn’t have been more helpful. From finding the best local fish tacos and conch fritters to visiting the Hemingway house, your staff is 5 stars in my book and I really do apologize for not being able to remember more of their names. And don’t get me started on Jordan, that cat has it made!

We stayed in room 2 at the Merlin Guesthouse, it was perfect. My first time in Key West, so I didn’t plan on spending too much time in there regardless, but it was a luxury to come back to after a night out on Duval St.  From the hot shower to that extremely comfortable bed, I wouldn’t change a thing. Room service was swift but thorough with their cleaning and although the lady didn’t speak much English she may have been the only person in Key West with a bigger smile than mine.  This may seem weird, but I like that the same lady cleaned our room both days we were there.  It shows that you trust your employees and it also helps the tenant feel safer about not having to worry about different people being in and out of their room every day, so for that I thank you.

My friends, by now, are probably sick of hearing how much I loved your place. But I don’t really mind talking about it, because I know as soon as they stay, they’ll be doing the same thing. The one day we were there, we tried going to the beach but the wind proceeded to blow harder and harder and it made laying on the beach a bit too unbearable. So we went back to the Merlin Guesthouse, got in the pool (which was the perfect temperature) and had a blast. It was a weekday, which I’m guessing explained the quietness of the pool area, but I didn’t mind it one bit.

The day we left, we did the usual touristy thing and had our pictures taken at the Southernmost point. Reading the history behind it all was a huge plus for us. From there, we made our way to the Ernest Hemingway house which was a very cool experience. After that, we took a final stroll down Duval St to hit up one of those cookie shops that displays a basketball sized cookie in the front window, couldn’t pass that up :)… Aside from those places, only one restaurant/cafe set itself apart from the others and I was lucky enough for it to only be a few blocks down Simonton Street from where we stayed. It was a vegan place called Sugar Apple. I must tell you that I have had no previous experience with vegan food. I am a very carnivorous guy and I love my meat. My girlfriend, on the other hand, she lived a semi-vegan lifestyle so of course she had to try it. I will tell you this, I’m glad we did. We split two meals and they were some of the best sandwiches I’ve ever eaten. I always make an effort to try out local eateries when I visit a new place, and this, amongst a few others have earned a repeat customer.

On behalf of my girlfriend and myself, we would like to personally thank you for meeting and exceeding our vacation expectations. You guys go above and beyond to accommodate your guests and I would not change a thing about the way you conduct your business. Thank you for making our trip to Key West so amazing and know that you guys played a sole role in us returning at some point in our future vacations!

 

Your happiest tenant, Brandon Roof

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

5 / 5


Our room D2 was small but functional once staff provided mobile clothing rack. Perfect location & amazingly quiet for location. Thankx for access to early coffee (crucial!) & light breakfast @poolside. We walked EVERYWHERE & able to find our way back enjoyed seeing the lighthouse lit as we often returned late & bar CLOSED!  THX bartender who REOPENED to make our LAST nite drink.  Entire staff professional & helpful. Miss your shower!!!

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We have stayed at the Chelsea House many times. The staff have always been very helpful. We would stay at any of your properties in key west.

By: on November 24, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

5 / 5