Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.74 - based on 5114 reviews

Warm welcome at reception, all questions answered professionally. I had emailed before hand to request if gluten free bread was available & the receptionist showed me a couple of choices that she had just purchased for me to make sure all was ok – amazing ! Breakfast was fresh & welcoming & staff very helpful & pleasant. Room was small and clean & quirky perfect for a couple of nights stay. We could ask no more & should we come back to Key West would not hesitate to stay here again. Thank you.

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


My boyfriend and I came across the Lighthouse Court Hotel just a few days before our stay– the hotel that we normally stay in was all booked, so we decided to give it a go based on other reviews and mostly the location, and are glad we did!

The front desk was very nice & accommodating, parking was painless and our rooms were even ready an hour before promised. The pool was a perfect way to relax and cool off once we arrived (along with the mojito bar, which had great drinks) and other guests were friendly, too. The room itself exceeded our expectations– super clean, and had a small kitchen/living area separate from the bedroom.

The location was maybe the best part, as we were a 10-15 minute walk/even shorter bike ride from most of the spots we wanted to check out in Key West. Also neat to stay across from the Hemingway House. Hotel is close to a lot of restaurants, cafes, shops but still quiet & relaxing.

Overall, we seem to have found a new favorite spot in Key West, and would definitely stay here again!

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We enjoyed our entire 3 day weekend!  Our room was perfect and access to the porch was great.  We thought the pool was perfect, positioned great to get all day sun. Staff was very polite and nice.  Access to Duval Street was great to enjoy all the activities.  Truly a great experience! 

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


Wir hatten sehr schöne 2 Tage im Cypress House Hotel und wurden sehr nett empfangen. Der Check-In war herzlich und unkompliziert. Unser Zimmer war sehr geräumig und vor allem sehr sauber. Die Pool-Area ist nicht groß, aber dafür sehr gemütlich eingerichtet. Das Frühstück ist für amerikanische Verhältnisse gut und die lime-hour am späten Nachmittag gibt es sogar eine lime-hour mit Getränken und kleinen Snacks eine schöne Idee. Die Lage ist super. Alles schnell erreichbar und nur eine Straße von der bekannten Duval-Street mit großem Restaurant- und Barangebot entfernt. Wir würden das Hotel jederzeit weiterempfehlen und sicherlich noch einmal wiederkommen.

Grüsse aus Hamburg/Germany

Manuela & Sven

 

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


From the location, to the accommodations themselves, to the knowledge of the staff, as well as their willingness to help, we can’t say enough about our stay.  Will definitely recommend to others as well as stay again when we make our way back to town.  Thanks so much!

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


With my group of 28 people for a wedding party, the week of May 9th-May 16th, The Hunter Wedding Party, I cannot express the gratitude I have for so many employees of Merlin Guest House. Let’s start with Mary Simmons, a High School friend but one with knowledge and patience from the start to finish with our group, contract, to arrival of gifts and boxes for the wedding, even her personal time and steamer when we were in a jam with the Bride’s gown. Mr. Kenneth and Linda- their knowledge of the island and patience with our group, towels poolside, taxi calls and service from the cleaning staff keeping things in order and asking what we needed for anything of service, the maintenance guys for the additional mini fridges we needed for medical purposes for some guests. The location and the property itself is one the entire group is still chatting about and we are anxious to come back to celebrate for the next group outing.

Thank you so much and appreciate everything from the bottom of our BIG Texas hearts and hope to share more fun with Merlin Guest House again. Whisker tickles to Jordan from Pegs!

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

5 / 5


This is the second year we have stayed at the Merlin Guest House and we just love how relaxed and quiet the experience has been both years. The shaded outdoor area, the pool, and the rooms are always welcoming and low key in all the right ways. The staff is always helpful, friendly, and available. The location could not be better. We have recommended the hotel to friends and will continue to. Thank you for providing us an experience we look forward to all year!

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

5 / 5


We stayed for our 10th wedding anniversary.  Upon arrival we were greeted by 2 smiling faces who were very friendly.  We had been driving for 9 hours and my husband was not feeling great.  We got there early not expecting to be able to check in until 4pm.  To our surprise they allowed us to check in early.  The cottages at Key Lime Inn are very cozy and the property is quiet.  The room was small and very clean and smelled nice.  Unfortunately, my husband ended up in the ER later that night and I ended up sleeping in my car not getting to enjoy the room overnight.  We had to leave that morning & get him to our local hospital.  Once again not expecting it we asked if we could be refunded for the second night since we would be leaving.  To our surprise the friendly staff  had compassion for us and without hesitation refunded our second night.  Although we didn’t get to enjoy our weekend getaway we were very impressed with our short stay.  We will definitely be rebooking in the future.

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


My  husband and I had a fun time staying in one of  your cottages. The  front desk was very helpful in giving us maps and ideas.  The only improvement is that the was no indication that parking was an extra $10 fee, except on their website.  Luckily we have a handicap parking  placard and was able to park on the premises.  The room was clean and breakfast was tasty.

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


I was able to stay 2 nights at the Cypress House Hotel because I was in town for a wedding. But being at the Cypress House was like a luxury home away from home. The room was amazing. I had the library! Everything was clean, seemed like a new room. But it was historic! The bed was comfortable.  Great pool area! They had a healthy and great selection for breakfast.  A great way to start the day. The location was at the heart of the downtown area. 2 minutes walk to Duval street, where everything is Live!! Great restaurants and nightlife nearby. I enjoyed the Liming hour; a happy hour with a delicious drink and appetizers. Who could beat that!! And the hotel was for adults only. Even better. When I have to opportunity to return to key west, Cypress House Hotel will be the reason I return!

By: on May 24, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel


5 / 5