Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.74 - based on 4547 reviews

Represents the best of Key West. Young female bartender at Mojhito Bar was the best.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


I had the best stay yet on my 7th yr for Fantasty Fest this has been my favorite hotel…the room was perfect bed very comfy!!close to duval Mallory square. Had bikes with us didn’t need them the hotel is really centrally located to everything so u can walk. Breakfast was perfect and the grounds are gorgeous you just want to hang there all day with Jordan the hotel cat;)

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

5 / 5


Staff is always helpful and pleasant. My husband was sick while there and everyone from maid service to front desk was very caring. We could not ask for a better experience.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


This was our second stay at Merlin Guesthouse. It is amazing that it is so close to Duval yet so quiet — we love that!

We were impressed at the room updates made since our last visit two years ago. We requested the SAME room and luckily, it was available. The room was perfectly updated — very comfortable, clean and quiet.

The staff was great — all of them very helpful and courteous. We especially appreciated Gail’s help; she was filling in at the front desk. She went out of her way to help us with a boarding pass problem and we appreciate her extra effort. Also, we asked about other room layouts at the Merlin to plan our next visit (October 2016). She explained all the details, showed us photos and described the beautiful room choices. We were so pleased with her help that we decided to upgrade to a one bedroom suite for our next visit; we are already looking forward to it!

We enjoyed the daily patio breakfast, the lovely pool area and the overall attractiveness and good upkeep of the property.

We always come to Key West during Fantasy Fest and like to be able to get away from the craziness for some peace and quiet. The Merlin Guesthouse totally delivers on this and we have recommended it to friends.

We look forward to our next visit!

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

5 / 5


The hotel has a lot of charm and is very welcoming and comforting. We will definitely stay again.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


The hotel has a perfect location and the rooms were great. Cozy and just what we needed.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


What my wife and I loved the most was how centrally located the Key Lime Inn was to the “action” that is Key West. A short block and a half walk and you’re on Duval Street. This was our 4th visit to KW and each time we’ve tried a different property with this being one of the top two. When we arrived we were greeted by Michelle at the front desk. She was phenomenal! She gave us the 411 on the property including all the amenities (pool, restrooms, ice and vending machines, etc…) and gave us the lowdown on how they do breakfast every morning. We have our favorite spots for breakfast in KW but this can run you $20 to $30 (for 2 people) each morning. The Key Lime Inn offered a complimentary breakfast by the pool each morning with local bagels, muffins, tea, coffee, fresh fruit, yogurt, cereal, oatmeal, etc… which over a few days would save you a few pennies. We only got shut out of parking in the main lot one night (Friday) as we got back late but not so worry as their sister property is right next door and we parked in their lot, which is allowed. Most of the rooms that we noticed are away from the main street which is always nice as it cuts down on the noise from the constant flow of cars and scooters. Even the pool, which is directly behind the main building, is somehow shielded from the noise. The hotel is a short 7-8 minute drive to any of the 3 main beaches in KW (Smather’s, Higgins or Fort Zachary Taylor). Both check and check out were a breeze. I would definitely recommend this property to anyone looking for a nice quaint hotel in Key West.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


My husband and I are from New York and were in town for my best friend’s wedding. We stayed at the Key Lime Inn and could not be more satisfied with our stay. The rooms were absolutely beautiful, beds comfortable, housekeeping met our needs and the staff made our visit stress-free. We look forward to staying at the Key Lime Inn again for our next visit. Thank you so much.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


Upon our arrival, check in was flawless.  John was very helpful in getting us situated and made us feel welcome.  Umberto and Lyenna were also professional and friendly throughout our 4 days.  The Chelsea House was one of our favorite stops, and one of the best, on the parade on Friday night.  The pool decks were favorite meeting places for us to meet other guests and enjoy the amenities. We could relax in the shade or bask in the sun, given our options.  Chelsea House was a Rock Star hit for us.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


We ended up coming into Key West a day early and were able to book a room at the Key Lime because the place where we booked the rest of our stay didn’t have any openings that night. What an unexpected treat! Our room was beautiful and opened up to the pool area. After checking into our next hotel we were both disappointed as our new place wasn’t nearly as nice as Key Lime Inn. The next time we are in Key West there is no doubt where we will be staying. Thank you for such a lovely spot.

By: on November 9, 2015
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5