Guest Testimonials | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.
Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.69 - based on 813 reviews

 

My husband and I stayed at the Merlin Guesthouse for 4 nights. The location is perfect and the rooms were clean and comfortable. We stayed in the economy queen and it was great. It opens up to a long porch, great for relaxing, reading or having a cocktail. The location is great for walking to Duval.

By: on January 26, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

5 / 5


 

We really enjoyed our stay at the Lighthouse Court. Our king sized room was a good size and we were right off the pool which was a great location. I liked the character the hotel had and it was a great location. So nice to walk across the street to go to the Hemingway House. The only complaint was the bathroom. Other than that, we liked the hotel.

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

We had a great stay at your Inn and if we ever return to Key West we will stay at one of your hotels for sure! The rooms were clean and your continental breakfast was perfect. forget perfect they were AMAZING… stuffed croissants WOW. The staff was always very helpful and kind as well. The cats are nice companions that keep you company at the pool. you are literally 1 block from the main strip. Duval street. walking distance to to everything major. we absolutely loved this hotel and are looking fwd to spending many more New Years in the Keys.

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

5 / 5


 

I love to try a variety of b&bs, inns, hotels, etc. This place is a combo of all three. Beautiful individual buildings with charm, great location.

Store bought, well provisioned outdoor breakfast by the pool. Only 4 tables so u still get that close chatting with your table mates feel of a b&b. Pool is small, includes jets& wasn’t heated when we were there- however if u go in knowing that it is easily one of the most beautiful places for a dip or to sun!

Helpful staff, great places.

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

4 / 5


 

We spent 3 nights over the New Year at Chelsea House. Our reception was extremely efficient and welcoming for us and our German Shepherd who we decided to bring at the last moment. The property has 8 pet-friendly rooms so make sure they can accommodate your pet in advance. Our room was clean, comfortable and parking was convenient and included with our package. As noted in other reviews, we did not have a closet but there were hooks to hang clothing in the room. The pool area is nice and gardens are lush. The location is perfect for walking to all of the venues on and surrounding Duval Street. We enjoyed our stay very much and will definitely stay at Chelsea House again.

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

4 / 5


 

My partner and I had a great stay at The Chelsea House in Key West over the at the end of 2012. Bryan, the host greeted us on our arrival and although we had only spoken on the phone he was friendly, warm and very helpful. When we walked in the front door he seemed genuinely glad to see us and made us feel very welcomed. The guesthouse and ground were well maintained and the pool sparklingly clean. The clothing optional deck was private and comfortable. Our room was beautiful furnished, well maintained and spotless and the king size bed very comfortable. The staff were friendly and helpful and the property is lucky to have Bryan on hand to welcome the guest and keep things flowing in a professional but friendly way!!

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

5 / 5


 

Loved the vibe of this place the minute we pulled in. The grounds were very tropical and little paths around the individual “cabins” were fun to stroll around. There were just little touches like a tree swing and the private little patios adjoining the individual detached rooms were a nice surprise. The room was immaculate, well appointed, very restful…cherrywood floors, tropical pastels, palm fans over the four poster bed. All that and a five minute walk to Duval Street. I will definitely stay there again. There are those people that insist that you are at Key West for the night life and a room is just a place to sleep; I disagree. After a busy day and great evening out the prospect of returning to a special retreat is important…the frosting on a cake. Or should I say, the chocolate coating on Key Lime Pie on a stick!

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


 

We stayed at the Key Lime Inn recently while in Key West on business. It was so nice to have parking on site! Breakfast was adequate, though served late one morning and that happened to be a morning of 9:00 meetings. We believe you could provide your guests a better night’s sleep with some new mattresses and hope that will occur before we return. Thank you!

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

3 / 5


 

On a whim a girlfriend and I decided to spend the night in Key West after only spending a few hours on Duval St. As we were walking towards our car we noticed a Vacancy sign on one of your sister Inns. We went into the reception area in hopes that we would find a room for the night. The front desk agent was extremely helpful and friendly. She was able to call Key Lime Inn to make sure they still had one room left, out of all six properties we were luckily enough to get the very last room, she checked us in at that location and gave us great directions to Key Lime. So that when we arrived we knew we had the room. We received our keys and once again had very friendly front desk agents assisting us. We walked to our room and walked in and were very pleased with our decision to stay with your resort. The room was spacious, clean, and decorated very nice. The refrigerator came in handy. The location was perfect for our Duval Crawl, no taxis needed. I would stay and recommend it to all of my friends. We do plan on going back to Key West to spend more time there, and certainly considering using your resorts again!

Thank you for a wonderful experience!

By: on January 22, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


 

We can’t say enough to say how much we enjoyed our stay. The Staff is #1!!  From the office staff to the lady that cleaned our room. They went out of there way to make our stay the best we have had in our 6 trips (first time there) to Key West.  The room was so clean and we enjoyed the Liming hour meeting other guests. Friendly, warm, funny, giving you a family caring for you feeling. And a thanks to Lady Bug for her warm greetings and company by the pool! We were there for our 35th anniversary and can’t wait to come back.  We have and will recommend anyone going to Key West to try the  Cypress House.  Thank you again to the staff of the Cypress House for making our time there the best!!!!

Margo & John  Mylott

By: on January 20, 2013
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House

5 / 5