Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.77 - based on 7265 reviews

 

Our bedroom (#6) was wonderful!!!  Staff were all very friendly and helpful.  Having the parking garage which we paid through the hotel worked out very well.  The sink in the bathroom, although very pretty is difficult to use because of the depth.  The cooked part of the breakfast was not great looking and the same thing was out for the 2 days we were there for breakfast….we didn’t try it but maybe it was good…..the location was great….we would definitely stay here again on a trip to key west.  Loved the drinks and snacks in the afternoon ‘Liming’ ….fish pate was excellent!!!

By: on December 10, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

4 / 5


 

The Merlin Guesthouse was a perfect place for me to stay while I was in town for one of my best friend’s wedding in Key West.  Especially as I was traveling alone without family, I wanted a safe place, centrally located and warmly welcomed.  Even though I arrived after the 10pm check in time when your office was open, Kenneth was kind enough to offer to stay an extra 1/2 hour to check me in, hand me my key and show me my room.  The room was clean, quiet, cozy and soothing.  Breakfast the next morning was good assortment of strong coffee, cold orange juice, blueberry muffins, bagels/toast apples, and yogurt.  Perfect options for a lite breakfast to start the day.  The courtyard was beautiful and the tables and chairs were charming and comfortable.  The only thing to make this stay a 5 star was an improvement on the bed and pillows.  My bed had no support in the mattress and the pillows were very thin and uncomfortable.  By the second night, my back was aching as much from all the walking and wedding prep as the no support in the bed.  With a better mattress and fluffier pillows, this would’ve been a 5 star rating.  Staff were great, place was clean, location was ideal and easy to get to everywhere with a short walk, air conditioning and tv a plus, and felt like a very “historic” key west property.  Worth another visit if I can ensure a better mattress!!

By: on December 6, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guest House

4 / 5


 

Such a wonderful little place, perfect for any length of stay in Key West. Lovely friendly staff and beautiful rooms, we had a fantastic 2 night stay

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


 

Stayed at the Albury Court for one night  at the end of November…  The hotel is clean and comfortable… maintained and fulfilled my expectations. I stayed in a guestroom which faced a hardware warehouse …. not a great view… but to be honest for the amount of time I stayed… it was not an issue.  The continental breakfast was good and tasty! The thing that made this place  for me… was the co workers… Lynne on the front desk was great…. as were the others working later the same day we arrived…. one minor issue that we had was sorted  with good customer service and understanding…  thanks guys!

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

I really enjoyed the little details such as when you arrive there is fresh ice tea beverage in the main office. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Good size parking lot.

The room was clean, however it smelled a little like cleaning detergent. This is the only improvement that I suggest. It may have been the air conditioning unit that was just cleaned.

Thanks!

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

3 / 5


 

We really liked our room at Lighthouse Court. The front porch is a very nice place to sit and relax before bed, the breakfast is good, the grounds are beautiful, the bed very comfortable. I would suggest more racks for hanging clothes and shelves in the bath for toiletries. Great staff and drinks at the Mojito Bar by the pool were excellent. The hotel is in an excellent location, near everything we wanted to see and do.

We liked Blue Heaven for breakfast (eggs benedict and the omlette). Also the Six Toed Cat had  a wonderful pink shrimp salad… a little spicy but delicious. Their Key Lime pie was to die for.  Joe had the fish of the day sandwich, which was snapper and he loved it. For dinner, we liked Blackfin Bistro and Louie’s Backyard (on the water). It was pricey but upstairs you could have tapas and drinks if you were not that hungry.  Also, drinks were served on the deck on the water.  Beautiful view.  We had reservations for dinner, but we were not that hungry to warrant the price…thus drinks on the deck.  The view of the ocean is truly beautiful from the deck.

I loved the Butterfly Conservatory. It was just amazing.  It is very close to Louie’s.  If you have kids, this is a place that they would love.  There are also tropical birds flying around you with this lush foliage everywhere.  The sunset in Mallory Square is not to be missed.  Also, Hemingway’s is a must see.

There were cute shops everywhere, but I was not interested in shopping.  I did buy a cute mug at the Six Toed Cat.

The whole island is historically very interesting.

 

 

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

My husband and I had a wonderful off-season trip the last week of November, 2012 while staying at the Key Lime Inn. The king-sized bed was so very comfortable, the grounds were relaxing and the pool refreshing. Thanks for your hospitality, it showed all over the property. We were thrilled to be in walking distance of  the El Siboney Restaurant – the Cuban food is terrific! We can’t wait to return to the Key Lime Inn!

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


 

We enjoyed our stay very much. It was great to be so close to the harbor & dock for the Key West Express and that we could store our luggage after checkout before our departure.   Ray and all staff that we encountered were very friendly.  We definitely will recommend your hotel to our family and friends.

Thanks – The Weavers

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

4 / 5


 

Wanted to let you know we had a delightful experience at Albury Court. Very spacious room (#31)  Great breakfast, short distance to all fun activities! When we return, rest assured we’ll be booking with you. Sorry that I missed your pooch, oh well, next time. Most Sincerely, Dorothy+Brian

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

5 / 5


 

We recently stayed at the Key Lime Inn during a short trip to Key West and found the historic house to be completely charming, clean and inviting. The staff was friendly and attentive and the location is unbeatable. We loved walking “home” each night after a fun time on Duval street to such a beautiful and comfy place!

 

By: on December 3, 2012
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5