Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.75 - based on 5747 reviews

We really enjoyed our time at the Lighthouse Court Hotel.  It is a quiet piece of paradise in the very busy Key West.  Located, across the street from the Ernest Hemingway House, it is in the perfect location.  Just enough off of Duval street, but close enough to walk to everything.  Staff is friendly and responds to requests very quickly.  The continental breakfast is good and offers more than most hotels.  Make sure you try the cheese and ham stuffed croissants; they are great and made fresh locally.  The pool was larger than we expected and well maintained.  In fact, the whole hotel was pretty and well maintained.  The parking lot they provide is a short walk away and easily accessible.  Overall, our stay was very good and we would definitely return again.

By: on April 15, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


Our very first trip to Key West and it did not disappoint!  After much consideration and not knowing where to stay in Key West, my family and I decided on the Lighthouse Court Hotelfor the week prior to Easter 2016!  This is a fabulous place to enjoy the ambiance of Key West, and the convenience of being one block from Duval Street.  Park your car and Walk everywhere – very easy!

We absolutely loved the room and it was very clean and a comfortable setting:  queen beds, sitting area, large shower / bathroom, and a private patio area for morning coffee or afternoon cocktails.  We were pleasantly surprised to be visited every day by Gary Cooper (the resident master cat) – he was a delight!

We certainly did appreciate the breakfast offerings, which were conveniently located in the patio area where there is also an in-ground pool with plenty of lounge chairs and tables to choose from.   We did take advantage of the pool too.

The entire staff at the Lighthouse:  from the front desk – check-in and check-out were a breeze; to the bartender(s), to the grounds/maintenance crew, and our housekeeping – I can’t say enough complimentary things about them, they were all delightful.  When we asked questions about things to do/go in Key West, whether it was a restaurant, guided tours, beach recommendation – they were all happy to oblige our requests and spot on with their recommendations.

The restaurant recommendations in Old Town were great:  Two Friends, Blue Heaven, Garbo’s Grill, La Tratorria (Vigilio’s); Willie T’s.

We can’t wait to plan our return to Key West!!

P.S.  Loved the roosters too – they did start up around 3 AM (I am told) but they did not bother me a bit.

By: on April 15, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We have been staying at the Albury Court Hotel on our mostly yearly visits to Key West for the last ten years. The hotel rooms are clean and neat always and reasonable value for Key West. The Staff are always friendly and very helpful.  We will continue to stay there any time we visit Key West.

By: on April 15, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

3 / 5


I can’t imagine us staying anywhere else! Great friendly staff, cleaning crew amazing. Rooms always comfy and relaxing. Pool area is lovely. So nice and quiet, no kids running around. Perfect couples get away. We recommend this place to everyone . We stay here twice a year. We have had great dinners all over the island, but this last trip we fell in love with La Ti Da! The food, atmosphere, the owner Christopher is such a sweetie. Piano bar, outside bar love it all thanks!

 

By: on April 15, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


We are so glad we chose this hotel out of the many hotels in Key West! Right away we liked the area and the authentic key west look with the porches and verandas shaded by palm trees! The staff was wonderful-friendly and courteous and very helpful. John especially gave us some great ideas for things to do and places to eat. We followed up on his recommendations and had a great time! He also helped with reservations and taxi service. Thanks John!

The hotel was very nice, the pool was great to relax in at the end of the day, the grounds were attractive and breakfast was good . There was a variety of food and beverages for breakfast on the patio and coffee throughout the day in the hotel lobby. We walked or rode a bike everywhere from the hotel. It’s not far from anything! The only complaint, and it’s minor, is the outlet (floor level) that we were trying to use to charge our phones was old and our chargers would not stay plugged in. We had to unplug the tv and use that outlet. Also, there was a light switch next to the door that didn’t appear to go to anything. It would have been nice to be able to come in at night and just hit the switch to turn on a light. But these were far from deal breakers. The room was very nice and the bed very comfortable! We will definitely stay at Chelsea House Hotel again!

By: on April 14, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Hotel

5 / 5


Awesome experience. Everyone was friendly and helpful. Room was clean and modern. Liming hour was wonderful. In walking distance from everything. Breakfast was delicious. Will definitely stay here again!!!

 

By: on April 12, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Cypress House Hotel

5 / 5


I recommended the Key Lime Inn for a long weekend in Key West for myself, my husband and 6 others.   I loved our rooms and so did the rest of our party.   3 of the 4 rooms were around the pool.  It was like we had a private courtyard and pool.  The continental breakfast was good.   Gail who checked all of us in was extremely helpful in anything we asked her.  She is an asset to your company for sure.  Our King Deluxe room was awesome, roomy and very clean.  All our & my groups rooms were the same way.  I have stayed here before and will again.   My favorite restaurant to eat at is the New York Pasta Company, well within walking distance. For breakfast Pepes, for lunch BO’s.  We walked everywhere.   Gail helped us get a taxi to get to Mallory Square when we were tired.   If you let them know at the front desk what you are looking for, they may have discount coupons.  We also enjoyed the show at 801.  Great place, will definitely stay again.

By: on April 12, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


Lighthouse Court is an absolutely beautiful hotel that is closely located to all the shopping, restaurants and the Mallory Square sunset celebration. The hotel staff really treats you like you’re someone special and appreciates your business. The hotel manager, Danielle, went out of her way to help us with anything that we needed. And Maria, the front desk clerk treated us so special, too, helping us with anything we asked for including directions and recommendations. The hotel has a great breakfast buffet every morning that you can enjoy eating poolside. It also has a cute little mojito bar, poolside. It is landscaped like a tropical paradise that makes you never want to leave. We spent one week there and absolutely cannot wait to return. We miss it already and we only got home three days ago. Lighthouse Court Hotel is THE best!

By: on April 12, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We had a terrific visit in Key West. The Lighthouse Court Hotel was very nice. Staff was extremely helpful. We were very pleased that we were able to check in early. Pool was very tropical. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit.

By: on April 12, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


The hotel was small and cute. We had an issue with our AC the 1st night there and they promptly moved us to another room with no issue.  It was my BFs birthday and the hotel sent up champagne and chocolates to celebrate.  I thought that was so wonderful. The breakfast was a perfect continental breakfast every morning and the coffee was so good!  Everything was pretty close to the hotel and you can’t beat the price for sure. The only issue was you could hear some street noise. Try to stay in rooms away from the road and in the corner if you want it quieter. We did get a good deal and if we could get that same price every time we might stay again.

By: on April 12, 2016
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

3 / 5