Guest Reviews | Key West Hotel Reviews

Here you will find, in the words of our guests, trusted & authentic reviews for Historic Key West Inns hotels. These are reviews from guests who have stayed at each property, telling their experiences about their guestroom, the hotel and service from our Historic Key West Inns team.


Historic Key West Inns
725 Truman Avenue
Key West, Florida 33040 USA  |  Telephone: 800-549-4430
4.70 - based on 1889 reviews

I have stayed at lighthouse court on 3 separate occurrences. I love the pool, and breakfast selection. I think these are the 2 main amenities that bring us back each time. The room size was comfortable for the amount of days we stayed. However, the mattress and pillows were not adequate this time. The mattress was bumpy and the pillows were flat. Also, there needs to be 2 people in the office during the day hours. Whenever we needed to get our keys (because we have to submit them to the office) no one was in the office. They were out on the property for some reason or changing another car. Lastly, when the room was cleaned they didn’t seem to clean the bathtub. Check-in and Check-out were both easy.

This was the firs time I had any complaints. However, I would definitely stay there again since I had such a pleasant experience the first 2 times. I also would recommend this location to anyone that asks about future accommodations in Key West!

Thank you.

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


We just returned from the Key Lime Inn this past Thursday evening (5/22/14) and had a great time enjoying Key West.  We had an issue after the first night in our room, but Melissa went above and beyond to “make it right”.  It was nice that breakfast was included (by the pool no less!), but they needed to include more carb-free options.  Off-street parking was complimentary as well.  Luggage carts were available for use, but the ladies at the front desk did not inform us of them – we saw them after we lugged our bags to our room.  Scooter and bike rentals are only two blocks away and are a great way to see the island.  The best part of our trip was actually recommended to us by the Historic Key West Inns website, under the “To Do” tab – Mellow Ventures.  We booked Mellow Ventures one afternoon and enjoyed their three part excursion (snorkeling, paddle boarding and fishing) and had an amazing time!  We would definitely come back and stay here again. Great rooms, amazing location (in walking distance to most places) and hospitable staff.  You can’t go wrong staying here! :)

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


This is my second time staying here and as expected it was great. The only issue i had was the size of room number 8 since i was accustomed to the king suite last time, but either way i will be back. The staff are courteous and attentive and rooms are always clean

james obrien

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Merlin Guesthouse

4 / 5


We had a lot of fun in the city and well reception in Chelsea. We had a good impression and felt a very glad sensation in the hotel environment. We were very thankful to the attention of the hotel staff.

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Chelsea House Pool & Gardens

5 / 5


Having been to Key West several times, this was our first stay at Lighthouse Court.  Great location, very helpful staff and comfortable rooms.  The complimentary breakfast was a great way to ease into the day.  Great hotel!

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5


Hey there! Our visit to Lighthouse Court was amazing! Ray the bartender was absolutely fantastic! He was full of useful information and was even willing to write down directions for us on different venues we wanted to see! The housekeeping staff were very friendly! Breakfast was always delicious. The only thing that we were not happy with is the lack of space in our room. We were put in D5 which is a little small. We went to the front office and was told for 30$ more a night we could upgrade. Since we were on our honeymoon, we decided that money could be spent on other things instead of a bigger room. We plan on coming back for our anniversary!!

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

3 / 5


Good morning,

Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to leave a review along with the chance for a 3 night stay. I have visited Key West a few times however this trip was very special, it was a celebration for my older sister’s 30th birthday. It was a girls trip in ages ranging from 26-58 combined of family & friends. We had two rooms and were so happy when we arrived to the charming feel of the rooms. The sizes were great, the beds were comfy and the pool was perfect. We enjoyed the breakfast and the staff was pleasant. It was the perfect location for our family & friends to celebrate my sister’s birthday. We met a lot of great families celebrating  different occasions. One family their daughter’s wedding, a couple on their honeymoon and others vacationing.

It was so great to walk everywhere, very close to Duval! I have a background in the hotel business as well and it was so great to be enjoying my stay at a relaxing location. I also would like to mention how wonderful the woman was who made my reservations. She did everything seamlessly over the phone. I apologize I don’t remember her name.  If I could make one suggestion, perhaps hiring more staff to clean the rooms would help. We didn’t mind at all but due to the high occupancy we were not able to have our room serviced daily because they were just too busy. Like I said, not a deal breaker but is a good suggestion.

We would love to return and stay another long weekend.  Thanks again for a wonderful weekend.

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

5 / 5


We very much enjoyed our stay at the Key Lime Inn.  The cottages were very comfortable and cozy, and we didn’t have to climb stairs.  Breakfast was very nice.

Staff was helpful.  Convenient location.  Pool looked very inviting.  Free parking was great.  You will enjoy your stay.

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Key Lime Inn

5 / 5


Hotel was recommended by a friend who had stayed there before. We’ve both been to Key West multiple times and I like to stay somewhere different each time to explore the island. I would stay here again, great easy location to Duval and old seaport. Clean rooms with quality toiletries. Decent breakfast set up and clean pool. Love that there were no kids! Definitely stay in the future.

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Albury Court Hotel

4 / 5


The experience was truly great! Overall, the staff was friendly especially Pete at the bar and Matt, the property manager. Housekeeping was also wonderful and very attentive. We were very pleased with our stay and would love to stay there again. :)

By: on May 27, 2014
Hotel Reviewed: Lighthouse Court Hotel

4 / 5